The proposed regulations landed in February 2026. Fuel producers finally had something more substantial than a January 2025 notice to work with. And yet, if you spent the following weeks in producer calls or tax-planning sessions, one theme kept surfacing.
Treasury answered a lot. Treasury did not answer enough.
IRC 45Z was always going to be complicated. A technology-neutral credit tied to lifecycle emissions, layered on top of the OBBBA amendments, and running through a GREET model that keeps evolving. That combination guarantees ambiguity. The proposed rules closed some of it. Below are the pieces still sitting on producers’ desks, unresolved, as comment letters go out.
The 45ZCF-GREET Model Still Needs a Real Update
Ethanol producers, RNG operators, and biodiesel refiners all rely on the 45ZCF-GREET model to score their fuel. The version tied to Notice 2025-11 set a de facto floor of roughly -31 kg CO2e/mmBTU for manure-based RNG. Producers with cleaner operations argue that number does not reflect their actual carbon intensity.
The proposed regulations acknowledge negative CI scores are allowed for manure-derived fuel produced after December 31, 2025. What they do not do is release the updated model that would let those scores materialize. Until DOE publishes a revised 45ZCF-GREET, IRC 45Z math for the highest-value fuels stays capped by an outdated baseline.
That is not a technical footnote. For a manure RNG project, the difference between a -31 and a -50 CI score can move project economics by tens of millions across the credit window.
Foreign Feedstock Restrictions Need Sourcing Mechanics
OBBBA restricted feedstocks produced or grown outside the U.S., Canada, and Mexico. The proposed regulations repeat the restriction. They do not walk producers through how to prove origin.
You are left with questions any procurement team is now asking:
- What documentation satisfies Treasury for used cooking oil aggregated across dozens of suppliers?
- How do you attribute origin for tallow that changes hands through a rendering intermediary?
- Does book-and-claim have any role here, or is physical traceability the only acceptable path?
Producers importing feedstocks legally today need audit-ready answers. The proposed rules leave the burden on the taxpayer without spelling out what “reasonable” documentation actually looks like.
The 45Q Stacking Line Is Still Blurry
The anti-stacking rules under IRC 45Z are clearer than they were. A fuel producer who claims 45Z on renewable fuel cannot also claim 45Q on the carbon captured during that same production process. Fair enough.
Co-located projects are messier than that framing suggests. Consider an ethanol plant paired with a CCS project where only a portion of the CO2 stream is captured, and where the fuel producer and the capture entity are separate taxpayers. The proposed regulations offer examples, not a decision tree. Structuring counsel is still building bespoke models to figure out which entity should claim what, and how related-party rules interact with the look-through provisions.
For a fuller walkthrough of the anti-stacking mechanics and the qualified sale expansion, this <a href=”https://www.reunioninfra.com/insights/section-45z-proposed-regulations”>Section 45Z proposed regulations breakdown</a> unpacks the specific fact patterns Treasury addressed and the ones it deferred.
Registration Timing Is a Real Cash-Flow Problem
To claim IRC 45Z, a producer must be registered under Section 4101. Producers who sold fuel in 2025 but only completed registration mid-year now have a timing question. Does the credit attach only to gallons sold after the registration date, or can earlier 2025 gallons qualify once registration is granted?
Practitioners have argued both readings. The proposed regulations do not settle it cleanly. For a producer sitting on eight or nine figures of potentially creditable sales, that ambiguity is not academic. It changes how the tax equity structure gets modeled and whether a transferability deal can close on its original timeline.
The ILUC Question Is Not Actually Closed
The statute excludes indirect land use change from the emissions calculation for fuel produced after December 31, 2025. Good. Producers wanted that.
Here is the catch. The 45ZCF-GREET model, as currently constructed, embeds certain land-use assumptions inside its lifecycle math. Removing ILUC in principle is not the same as removing it in the model. Producers using soybean oil, canola, or corn as feedstock want Treasury and DOE to be explicit about how the revised model separates ILUC from direct land-use effects. Until that happens, IRC 45Z scoring for crop-based fuels sits on shaky methodological footing.
Conclusion
Comments on the proposed IRC 45Z regulations are due April 6, 2026. Every trade association representing biofuels, RNG, SAF, and animal-agriculture-linked producers is filing. The winners in this cycle will be the operators whose comment letters point Treasury to specific fact patterns, not general principles. This credit rewards specificity, and the final regulations will too.



